As Spring Training begins to wind down, and players start to really prepare for the year ahead, the Phillies still have one glaring question. Who will be this year’s 5th starter? The competition has come down to Jamie Moyer and Kyle Kendrick, the old veteran versus the up and coming young sinker-baller. Fans all over Phillies nation are pulling for Kendrick and they believe he has already earned his spot for the most part. I have quite a different opinion on the subject.
First off, I really am curious where the infatuation with Kyle Kendrick came from. Just last year many were writing him off as a career minor-league pitcher who lacks the stuff to get big league hitters out on a consistent basis. Fast-forward through a couple of goose eggs KK put up after September call-ups and a well-pitched Spring Training and now Kendrick is a savior. The fact of the matter is, Kendrick is still very much a question mark. Talk about a fickle fan base.
Secondly, Jamie Moyer did struggle pretty severely during the beginning of the season and those struggles were so bad early on that they really put a hurting on his overall numbers for the season. Since May 20th last season, Moyer’s ERA was a very respectable 4.05. It is unlikely that Kendrick could match that type of production over a full season at this point in his young career. Moyer is the type of pitcher, where to the casual fan, it is almost impossible to tell when he is actually “done”. His production does not rely on eye-popping readings on a radar gun, but on location and savvy. In 2007 it looked like the end for Moyer, after he posted a 5.01 ERA (slightly worse than last year), only to bounce back in 2008 with a 3.71 ERA with 16 wins. I would not be surprised at all to see a similar season but with an ERA somewhere in the mid 4’s.
Lastly and possibly most importantly, Jamie Moyer serves almost no purpose in the bullpen. Many will point to Moyer’s numbers last year out of the pen and use that as evidence that he can succeed there, but what many fail to realize is that Moyer pitched in 4 extended appearances where Pedro Martinez had starts rained out. This is unlikely to happen again and is not very efficient to waste a roster and bullpen spot on a pitcher who can only throw in long relief. Moyer has also stated he cannot pitch on back to back days, which is critical for a bullpen arm. Moyer is not the type of pitcher who can be used as a lefty-specialist and is not a late-inning arm.
Tags: Jamie Moyer, Johnny G, kyle kendrick, Phillies
You must be logged in to post a comment.